On The Insider: Holy Cleavage!
BNET Business Network:
BNET
TechRepublic
ZDNet

By Matt Hines
Posted on ZDNet News: Aug 27, 2004 6:43:00 PM

A problem in the Service Pack 2 update for Windows XP may keep owners of AMD-based computers from using the long-awaited security package under certain circumstances, according to Microsoft.

In an article posted in the Knowledge Base section of its Web site, Microsoft says that Service Pack 2 may not work with computers running Advanced Micro Devices' 64-bit microprocessors. The Redmond, Wash.-based company said earlier that owners of such PCs may want to bypass the update completely, but has now come up with a workaround.

AMD's 64-bit chips include the Athlon 64 for PCs and the Opteron for servers.

A Microsoft representative declined to comment directly on the AMD-related issue but said the company "continually investigates all issues and vulnerabilities" reported to it regarding SP2 and other products.

Click here to 

Play

However, an AMD representatives said the chipmaker believes the problem has only occurred, so far, with one application, Sigma Designs' Realmagic Hollywood Plus DVD Decoder. Microsoft also identifies the application as being able to cause the problem.

Microsoft said in its advisory that PCs with 64-bit AMD processors may restart repeatedly after installing Service Pack 2, if those machines are also configured to enforce so-called data execution prevention (DEP) and contain hardware that requires a driver software known as Mpegport.sys. Sigma Designs' Realmagic Hollywood Plus DVD decoder application is one such application that uses the driver, the software maker said.

Microsoft says users may be able to resolve the problem by configuring a so-called DEP exception. AMD also recommends that people affected by the problem do so. Earlier, Microsoft had advised AMD users to remove SP2 altogether.

The AMD problem is the latest in a slew of issues that have dogged SP2 since it was first released to PC manufacturers at the beginning of August. By mid-month, Microsoft had detailed some 50 different software applications and games that may encounter problems with the update.

The potential for conflicts caused some high-profile businesses, including IBM, to order their employees to avoid installing SP2 until its ramifications can be better understood. Other organizations are moving forward with the update, expecting that its security enhancements outweigh the integration issues.

Microsoft has launched a do-it-yourself kit to help IT professionals assess their software's compatibility with the update. The compatibility guide, which can be retrieved from Microsoft's Download Center, is designed to help administrators "test and mitigate application compatibility issues."

  • Talkback
  • Most Recent of 99 Talkback(s)
good call
I've used AMD since the K6-2 days and have had zero compatibility problems as a result of using AMD. AMD64 is also proving to be rock-solid. In my experience AMD runs windows better than Intel - and... (Read the rest)
Posted by: zeusfuse Posted on: 10/04/04 You are currently: Logged In as: a Guest  | Login | Terms of Use
Nice headline  bidemytime | 08/27/04
AMD Could be the problem here  gary.douglas@... | 08/27/04
But the story said...  bidemytime | 08/27/04
The problem also affects Intel CPUs  threedaysdwn | 08/27/04
This is Bull Schitt!!!  rdurso@... | 08/27/04
what?  doh123 | 08/27/04
It's neither...  techboy_z | 08/27/04
pitted  gary.douglas@... | 08/27/04
Whew!  bhanes@... | 08/27/04
DOH123 was right. You are wrong, as was the article writer.  Joel R | 09/08/04
Drivers are the achilles heel of the PC (NT)  P. Douglas | 08/27/04
Tell me about it  php_developer | 08/27/04
Non-sequitur  Yagotta B. Kidding | 08/27/04
Is mpegport.sys supplied by MS? i was trying to find out  The King's Servant | 08/27/04
How to find out  Yagotta B. Kidding | 08/27/04
Yeah but I don't have it.  The King's Servant | 08/27/04
Re: Non-sequitur  P. Douglas | 08/27/04
Re: Non-sequitur (Second Try)  P. Douglas | 08/27/04
Re: Non-sequitur (Third Try)  P. Douglas | 08/27/04
Re: Non-sequitur (Fourth [and Last]Try)  P. Douglas | 08/27/04
One other thing ...  P. Douglas | 08/27/04
One other thing ... (Second Try)  P. Douglas | 08/27/04
One other thing ... (Third Try)  P. Douglas | 08/27/04
M$ needs to pull back and admit they screwed up!  drichards1953 | 08/27/04
Dude, they'd have to go back to 1994, then!  Xunil_Sierutuf | 08/27/04
Fire Up The Delorean Doc, Marty's Got A New Mission  itanalyst | 08/27/04
It's a sad day  threedaysdwn | 08/27/04
A joke, right?  AmusedAtItAll | 08/28/04
No, experience.  threedaysdwn | 08/28/04
Migrating?  NemesisNL | 08/29/04
Back up Bubba Boy!  drichards1953 | 08/28/04
To date there are NO conflicts with SP2  Joel R | 09/08/04
What would you expect from MICROSUCKS ???  realitycheck101 | 08/27/04
Not MS  rpmyers1 | 08/27/04
This is not a bug  threedaysdwn | 08/27/04
hmm...inhell & m$ had to do something  mvaar | 08/27/04
Not quite true.  Joel R | 08/28/04
Then please explain this  Pinkerton | 08/29/04
Not portrayed to be  JBL312@... | 08/27/04
Incompatible  Yagotta B. Kidding | 08/27/04
What is MS telling people?  The King's Servant | 08/27/04
Might be able to fix the problem by…  JBL312@... | 08/27/04
Solving With Sufficient Progress In TS  ParadigmOdyssey | 08/29/04
who's not thinking?  ryusen | 08/27/04
What?  agottschald | 08/27/04
Why not tell the truth?  R.T.F.M. | 08/27/04
You are correct...  mvaar | 08/27/04
Is That The  ParadigmOdyssey | 08/29/04
Umm  threedaysdwn | 08/29/04
Make a BookMark Your In Luck  ParadigmOdyssey | 08/29/04
Not a SP2 or AMD64 problem!!  Guy Fawkes | 08/27/04
RE: Not a SP2 or AMD64 problem!!  JimOTR | 08/27/04
It is a piece of hardware in a PCI slot  The King's Servant | 08/27/04
Your arrogant and clueless remarks  madlikehell | 09/27/04
What is with ZDNet's talkback forums ???  MrEMann | 08/27/04
Wow. What did Intel have to do?  Yagotta B. Kidding | 08/27/04
This problem affects Intel chips as well  threedaysdwn | 08/29/04
Does this driver have WHQL certification?  The King's Servant | 08/27/04
When Pigopolists Fly  Yagotta B. Kidding | 08/27/04
Correct me if I am wrong but  The King's Servant | 08/27/04
Linux and DVDs  Yagotta B. Kidding | 08/27/04
because of Vendor IP, not evil empires.  balsover | 08/27/04
Not enough data  dberlindZDNet Moderator | 08/27/04
Not enough data? Think again.  dpbakeril | 08/27/04
I can tell ya this  mac@... | 08/27/04
That Was  ParadigmOdyssey | 08/29/04
At least there will be software available  American Pride | 08/27/04
Excuse me?  Judas I. | 08/27/04
Sure you do  American Pride | 08/27/04
What is clear ...  Judas I. | 08/27/04
Ahh, only atheists like Linux, huh?  Joel R | 08/28/04
Pride goeth before destruction, and an haughty spirit before a fall.  agottschald | 08/27/04
ANOTHER nickname change?  Linux_Developer | 08/27/04
and yet another reason...  ryusen | 08/27/04
What I mean to say is  loser_z | 08/27/04
poor ORIGINAL ZZ, now you have an idiot following you  Monkey_MCSE | 08/27/04
THE one and only  loser_z | 08/27/04
nonono...  ryusen | 08/30/04
No Problem with SP2  dony_z | 08/27/04
MS will make sure it works with AMD  American Pride | 08/27/04
Windows SP2 and AMD  mondoville | 08/27/04
Windows is working in the right direction  loser_z | 08/27/04
Leave it to Microsoft to break the finest processor available  BitTwiddler | 08/27/04
INTEL the finest processor  loser_z | 08/27/04
uhhh...  doh123 | 08/27/04
Rejoice!  Chiatzu | 08/28/04
It's neither Microsoft's nor AMD's fault.  Joel R | 08/28/04
But the story also said  bob@... | 08/27/04
Ignorant and Stupid Reporting!!!  rdurso@... | 08/27/04
Proof that AMD is just a chip company, not platform  Prognosticator | 08/27/04
You're right, and...  KOS-MOS | 08/27/04
You're both wrong, and...  Joel R | 08/28/04
good call  zeusfuse | 10/04/04
Experienced Windows users know . . .  CheeseToast | 08/27/04
SP2 on AMD 64  art@... | 08/27/04
Why would anyone use a realmagic decoder on Athlon 64?  SteveS_z | 08/28/04
if you want 64 bit support buy longhorn - lol  V Sanders | 08/28/04
I think you are wrong  NemesisNL | 08/29/04
why does a web page "windows update"  V Sanders | 08/30/04

What do you think?

advertisement
advertisement

Gifts for Geeks

advertisement
Click Here