On CNET: eMachines intros slim tower PC
BNET Business Network:
BNET
TechRepublic
ZDNet

By Munir Kotadia
Posted on ZDNet News: Nov 4, 2003 1:49:00 PM

Red Hat's chief executive has said that Linux needs to mature further before home users will get a positive experience from the operating system, saying they should choose Windows instead.

Linux is seen by Microsoft as its most dangerous competitor for desktop operating systems, and after a number of high-profile cases where government departments have switched from Windows to Linux-based systems, the OS has been making some progress. However, Red Hat said that the hype around desktop Linux is still mostly unfounded at the moment.

Matthew Szulik, chief executive of Linux vendor Red Hat, said on Monday that although Linux is capable of exceeding expectations for corporate users, home users should stick with Windows: "I would say that for the consumer market place, Windows probably continues to be the right product line," he said. "I would argue that from the device-driver standpoint and perhaps some of the other traditional functionality, for that classic consumer purchaser, it is my view that (Linux) technology needs to mature a little bit more."

Szulik gave an example of his 90-year-old father going to a local retailer in order to purchase a computer with Linux: "We know painfully well what happens. He will try to get it installed and either doesn't have a positive experience or puts a lot of pressure on your support systems," he said.

However, Szulik expects Linux to be ready in a couple of years after it has had time to mature. In the mean time, he is adamant that corporate users would be surprised by how much the operating system has to offer. "Consumers want USB drivers and digital camera support; but for the enterprise desktop, that is a little bit different--that area is ripe," he said. "We think that the enterprise desktop market place is much more strategic and has buyers whose needs we can exceed."

  • Talkback
  • Most Recent of 111 Talkback(s)
But Windows XP is Broken
Windows 98 second edition was a good version
of Windows. But you had to purchase the
C++ compiler for it seperately.
Windows XP is BROKEN. Every time you reinstall
Windows XP you have to ... (Read the rest)
Posted by: ericmatteson2001 Posted on: 02/19/04 You are currently: Logged In | Log out
Finally someone who agrees. jonbob   | 11/04/03
And missed Lindows voska   | 11/04/03
Lindows? Not ready for primetime marksashton   | 11/04/03
why? stephen732@...   | 11/04/03
read me files? Ardian Daka   | 11/04/03
Should have mentioned Macintosh... gtdworak   | 11/04/03
Re: Should have mentioned Macintosh... issthatso   | 11/04/03
no reason stephen732@...   | 11/04/03
tco pschroeder@...   | 11/04/03
there's a reason jonbob   | 11/04/03
Sure you understand proprietary? Fred Fredrickson   | 11/04/03
please autofill this field none none   | 11/04/03
Re MACSSUCK   | 11/04/03
OS X ain't available on x86 - so non-issue MeMyselfAndI_z   | 11/04/03
Non-issue JoeError   | 11/04/03
RedHat changes target OhMyGosh   | 11/04/03
don't believe it! screaming silence   | 11/04/03
Huh???? heatlesssun   | 11/04/03
same people stephen732@...   | 11/04/03
cars pschroeder@...   | 11/04/03
odd, that jonbob   | 11/04/03
I suppose the same people Fred Fredrickson   | 11/04/03
Linux is better than windoze everywhere? mamuka.khantadze@...   | 11/04/03
Redhat isn't ready RedHat9User   | 11/04/03
LOL voska   | 11/04/03
You will never... BitTwiddler   | 11/04/03
Screaming ignorance rises again! marksashton   | 11/04/03
no longer Top Dog Joe Blow_z   | 11/04/03
Hadn't heard this before. Yeah right. heatlesssun   | 11/04/03
So based on your logic ... GLMarx   | 11/04/03
Not "never" IT_User   | 11/04/03
Honesty.... BitTwiddler   | 11/04/03
Media Center PC's and Linux heatlesssun   | 11/04/03
Myth TV has it's advantages voska   | 11/04/03
What does MCE not do for you? heatlesssun   | 11/04/03
Hey I'm movie collector, I have 1000s voska   | 11/04/03
Hey I'm movie collector, I have 1000s voska   | 11/04/03
Intresting. heatlesssun   | 11/04/03
My secret voska   | 11/04/03
Even Red Hat knows Linux is blowout Mike Cox   | 11/04/03
Ref: Even Red Hat knows Linux is blowout grumpy_trumpy   | 11/04/03
Re: Even Red Hat knows Linux is blowout issthatso   | 11/04/03
Wow, Linux really zooms against M$ in those Netcraft numbers! dicktaurus@...   | 11/04/03
you failed basic reading compression didnt you... henrystamp   | 11/04/03
Your company buys home computers? IT_User   | 11/04/03
From a guygiving up the home desktop market?!? Back-stabbing, if true! dicktaurus@...   | 11/04/03
deal with it. vdraken   | 11/04/03
IT's ready voska   | 11/04/03
Linux *is* Ready... Delaware Boy   | 11/04/03
No, it is not. vdraken   | 11/04/03
You logic fails you voska   | 11/04/03
profiles pschroeder@...   | 11/04/03
RE: You logic fails you nrlz   | 11/04/03
ready out of the box??? ambiguity   | 11/04/03
Nothing is "confirmed." NOT "everyone's" been saying it. Further... dicktaurus@...   | 11/04/03
oh yeah?!? first last   | 11/04/03
In a FUD war, don't underestimate the power of words. dicktaurus@...   | 11/04/03
knickers in a bunch first last   | 11/04/03
Wasted my time DarbyOhara   | 11/04/03
please autofill this field none none   | 11/05/03
Relax Man! Fanatical Desperado   | 11/04/03
Actually, Macs are far better for home users Yen_z   | 11/04/03
Macs pschroeder@...   | 11/04/03
WPA in Windows XP and other Microsoft products rcrow   | 11/04/03
WPA = Windows Product Activation pschroeder@...   | 11/04/03
correcting myself pschroeder@...   | 11/04/03
WPA = Windows Product Activation rcrow   | 11/04/03
More story Telling? John Zern   | 11/05/03
Noooooo! Goomba   | 11/04/03
you don't have to go back to MSW jfalknor   | 11/04/03
That OK Goomba   | 11/04/03
A very rational strategy. DonnieBoy   | 11/04/03
interesting indeed pschroeder@...   | 11/04/03
well Arrg   | 11/04/03
It's not the user experience he's dissing... Robert Carnegie   | 11/04/03
Home User ????? mikesonstegard@...   | 11/04/03
not very friendly to install? jfalknor   | 11/04/03
I HATE THE NEW TALKBACKS!!!! JoeMama_z   | 11/04/03
Everyone hates the new talkbacks Fanatical Desperado   | 11/04/03
re nrlz   | 11/04/03
Too bad :-( mbraincell@...   | 11/04/03
Foolishness mbratch   | 11/04/03
bad businessman? ambiguity   | 11/04/03
True and False Grimm Reaper   | 11/04/03
This confirms it Loverock Davidson   | 11/04/03
This confirms it runmad   | 11/04/03
Wrong Move rajeevkumarasthana@...   | 11/04/03
Goes for all versions of Linux for most users almonc   | 11/04/03
RedHat Linux is not a desktop winner Jose Jimenez   | 11/04/03
RedHat Linux is not a desktop winner kingnubian   | 11/04/03
Stick with Windows? Mil-spec-guy   | 11/04/03
Waiting to mature? SublimeDaze   | 11/04/03
A stake through the fanatics heart. No_Ax_to_Grind   | 11/04/03
Unless you said it, it must not be true FilledOut   | 11/04/03
12% stock drop jjon2121   | 11/04/03
All I know is this... Michael Kelly   | 11/04/03
Things are getting interesting kingnubian   | 11/04/03
He's right! George Mitchell   | 11/04/03
One user's experience Ex-Linux User   | 11/04/03
friggin hell sundru   | 11/04/03
Windows is not ready for the desktop drcrane   | 11/05/03
Who needs the desktop anyway? heepsd   | 11/05/03
Kernel panic, missing mounts, Xkill where FilledOut   | 11/05/03
a small note on operating systems perpetual-notion   | 11/05/03
Matthew Szulik is wrong ... indigo_z   | 11/05/03
How much did Bill GAtes paid him for this? :) maresal   | 11/08/03
Children Using Linux At Home. kira0030   | 11/09/03
Use Windows?????? Shadowman_z   | 11/13/03
Support for Joystick rajeevkumarasthana@...   | 11/19/03
Retailer less than disinterested? lugoteehalt   | 12/17/03
But Windows XP is Broken ericmatteson2001   | 02/19/04

What do you think?

advertisement
advertisement